What Insulation Should I Use? R-Value, Batts & Blown-In Explained

Have you ever stood in the insulation aisle wondering what all those R-numbers mean, or why there's pink fluff, gray fluff and foam boards? You're not alone. Insulation is one of those things every house needs and almost nobody explains.

In Part 1 of our insulation series on the How to Handyma'am podcast, Arly quizzed Samantha and Emily on the most common kinds of insulation. There was a little friendly competition and one imaginary buzzer. Here's the written version.

This episode is dedicated to Emily Warren Roebling, who taught herself engineering to help finish the Brooklyn Bridge and later fought for women's right to vote.

Handy Vocab: Words You'll See in This Post

  • R-value: How well a material resists heat moving through it. The higher the R-value, the better it insulates.

  • Studs: The vertical boards (usually 2x4s) that frame your walls. Insulation goes between them and drywall goes on top.

  • Thermal bridging: Heat escaping through things in your wall that don't insulate well, like wood studs. You can actually see it with a thermal camera: the studs show up as stripes.

  • Floof: The fluffy stuff. It's not technically a building term, but we're certified floofers.

Quick science moment: Heat always moves from warm to cold. Insulation's job is to keep the heat on the side you want it on: inside in the winter and outside in the summer.

The 5 Ways You Can Buy Insulation

Walk into any home improvement store and you'll see these five:

  1. Batts: Pre-cut sheets that fit between studs

  2. Rolls: Long rolls you cut to length (the classic pink stuff from commercials!)

  3. Loose-fill (blown-in): Fluffy chunks blown in with a machine. It looks a lot like bunny bedding.

  4. Spray foam: Sprayed in, then it expands to fill the space

  5. Rigid foam board: Stiff sheets of foam

There are plenty of specialty products out there (yes, even denim and sheep's wool), but these are the five most homeowners will run into.

Batts and Rolls: Fiberglass vs. Mineral Wool

Batts and rolls usually come in one of two materials:

  • Fiberglass: Millions of tiny slivers of glass. It looks soft, but it's not!

  • Mineral wool: Volcanic rock mixed with slag, a byproduct of making steel. They melt it down and spin it in a centrifuge, basically making lava cotton candy. Fiberglass is made the same way.

R-value: Both land at roughly R-3 to R-4 per inch, and mineral wool usually comes in a little higher. R-value adds up as the insulation gets thicker, so a thicker batt gives you a higher total. Most packages print the total R-value in big letters, like "R-13."

Where it goes: Between the studs of exterior walls and between rafters. If you find insulation in an interior wall, it's usually there for soundproofing or because the building is multifamily, where it's required.

Loose-Fill (Blown-In) Insulation: Cellulose vs. Fiberglass

  • Cellulose: Made from recycled paper products, like unused newspapers, that are partially pulped and shredded into floof.

  • Fiberglass: The same material as fiberglass batts, but packed into compressed bales. A machine breaks it back up and blows it into place.

R-value: On average, cellulose has a slightly higher R-value per inch. Cellulose also holds its R-value in extreme cold, and fiberglass settles less over time. With loose-fill, depth is what matters. Inspectors check an attic by standing a yardstick on the joists and seeing how high the insulation reaches.

Where it goes: Mostly attics and awkward, oddly shaped spaces. It can also be blown into existing walls through small holes, or from the attic if your house has balloon framing (studs that run in one continuous cavity from the basement to the attic).

⚠️ Safety note: If your house has knob-and-tube wiring, don't add insulation around it. Have an electrician take a look first.

Wait, paper insulation doesn't catch fire? Cellulose is treated with boric acid or ammonium sulfate, so it chars instead of bursting into flame. It can still be damaged, but it won't spread fire.

Don't Squish Your Insulation!

This is the biggest DIY takeaway. A lot of insulation's power comes from the air trapped inside it. When you compress it, you lose R-value.

  • Crammed a 4" batt into a 3" cavity? You get 3" worth of R-value, and probably less.

  • Laid plywood over blown-in insulation in your attic? It flattens the insulation and ruins its R-value.

If you need a higher R-value in a tight space, buy a product with a higher R-value per inch instead of squishing a thicker one in. Expect those products to cost more.

Never Touch Fiberglass with Bare Skin

Always wear gloves and long sleeves. Fiberglass gets into your skin like tiny splinters, and it hurts like heckity heck. If you do get some on you, duct tape can help pull it out. (Yes, we learned this the hard way, by tossing bales of it at each other in an attic six years ago. You don't have to!)

Samantha's Pick for Beginners: Mineral Wool Batts

If you want to add insulation yourself, start your research here:

  • They come in rectangles about 4 feet long, sized to fit between studs

  • They're friction-fit, so they hold themselves in place: no nails or screws

  • You can cut them, or just tear them by hand (with gloves on!)

Why This Matters, Even If You Hire It Out

Hiring someone to insulate your attic can cost a couple thousand dollars. If you understand R-value, you can ask your contractor exactly what you're getting and make sure it's the right amount for the space.

Your Homework!

Go look at the insulation in your attic or walls today. Is it batts, rolls, blown-in, or something else? Is there any at all? Tell us what you found in the comments!

Coming up: Part 2 of our insulation series will cover spray foam and rigid foam, and a future episode will help you track down where that cold air is coming from.

Keep Learning with How to Handyma'am

🎧 Listen to the full episode

🎉 New to DIY? Start with Handyma'am 101, our beginner YouTube series, and browse the Skill Library.

🛠️ Want to learn in person? Join the classes waitlist to hear first when registration opens.

🛒 Shop the tools and products we use on our Amazon storefront and our Lowe's picks, and rep the crew with our Handy as Heck merch. (Some links are affiliate links: we earn a small commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.)

💌 Want more? Join our newsletter for the week's episodes, or become a member on Patreon for our bonus SideQuests.

Full Episode Transcript

This transcript was generated automatically and lightly edited, so it may contain small errors.

Welcome to How to Handyma'am, the podcast where we're keeping it hot or not! That's right, today we're talking about insulation, so you can learn what forms it comes in, what R-value means, and what materials it's made of, so you can pick the right kind for your house.

I'm Samantha. I'm Arly. And I'm Emily. And this episode is dedicated to another Emily: Emily Warren Roebling, who we did a SideQuest about. She helped finish the Brooklyn Bridge and learned engineering while her husband was ill, just by watching engineering happen. She's really awesome. She ended up becoming a suffragette and fought for women's right to vote. So this is your reminder to register to vote. This will already be past the midterms, but for the next election, make sure you're registered.

Well, should we get into it? Let's do it!

The purpose of this podcast is to empower women to take care of their homes. Arly grew up handy, but my mom and I, six years ago, didn't have any of these skills or tools. We were you six years ago. So that tells you that you absolutely can do every bit of what we're doing. We want to be able to bring in-person education to women, and the podcast is our vehicle to get us started.

Three Minutes of Chaos

Welcome to the off-topic portion of our episode, aka Three Minutes of Chaos! Time is relative, my friends. One minute each. Arly has the question.

The question is: if you could learn a skill overnight, what would it be?

Mine's going to be fast. I would love to be able to play the piano. I love the sound of it, and I've learned a few songs and I love playing, but it's a lot of work. I want to just be good at it. I don't want to have to do the work to become good at it, which is probably every child who's ever taken piano lessons. The second thing I would learn would be to sing.

So you really just want to be a musician with none of the work.

Pretty much. I don't even have to do it for other people. I would just love to sit at a piano and pour out whatever emotions are overwhelming. I think it would be a good way to pour out love and joy and stress and frustration.

What would you be able to do?

I would pick computer coding, because I do a little bit, and it's very difficult. It's literally like another language. And I have so many creative ideas for apps and things that would be fun to produce. But I'm also not sciency, not mathy. So that's why I'd like to just wake up with the knowledge.

That'd be pretty cool. Someone would say, "You know what? This app would really help me," and you'd be like, "Give me 10 minutes."

It'd be called EI: Emily Intelligence.

What would you name your AI?

It would start as Carl, and then every version after would swap the C for a new letter. So Darl, Earl, Farl. And once I got to the end, we'd pick a new name.

Well, there you go, folks. How about you, Arly?

I would be really good at making espresso. Like very good at it, and know all the things.

You could just go work at a coffee shop and learn that skill.

But then you have to have all the equipment.

Well, you could just learn how to play the piano, Samantha.

That's fair. Although making espresso is probably slightly easier than becoming a concert pianist. A couple notches easier.

If I could wake up with a skill, it would also be the skill to remember things, because I cannot remember anything.

I have an addendum: I'd like to know how to trade stocks. Make a boatload of money.

I would like to be able to predict the future, and then I would buy lotto tickets.

I'd like to gain telekinesis.

Okay, before this turns into superpowers... If you timed our Three Minutes of Chaos, today was approximately four minutes.

Insulation 101

All right, what are we learning today?

Today we are going to learn about insulation! Let's insulate our brains with knowledge. We're not going to cover everything. We're going to learn the most useful beginner things: the basics of what insulation is, where it goes, and what the different types are. Because nothing is ever easy, and there are 15 million different types, but we'll give you some of the most common ones. Folks don't need to know everything about insulation. There's a specific kind for every tiny weird thing in the world, but that's not necessary for you to know.

Handy Vocab

Are we starting with Handy Vocab? Yes!

We're going to talk about R-value today, which is basically thermal resistance. It's how well insulation stops heat from moving through it.

Is a higher or lower R-value better?

A higher R-value is better. The higher the R-value, the more resistance, and the better the insulator. Fun fact: it's the inverse of how they rate windows, which use a U-value. But that's for another time.

We're also going to talk about thermal bridging. But first, studs. Studs are the 2x4s in your walls. They're usually vertical, and there's typically a horizontal one at the bottom and the top to hold everything together. They're what make up your wall. You'd put insulation between them and drywall on them.

So for thermal bridging: this happens when you have material in your wall that doesn't have insulating abilities. A 2x4 isn't insulation. It's wood, which means heat can travel through it. If there's nothing covering it, you have a bridge from the inside of your house to the outside that lets heat move right across, because wood has a really low R-value. The insulation in the other cavities means it won't happen as quickly, because your entire wall isn't wood. But you still have these bridges. If the bridges are blocked with something that has a higher R-value, you won't have all this heat leaking in or out.

I've seen people put a thermal camera on a wall, and you can see where the studs are, because the heat transfer is different on the studs than in the cavities between them.

One more quick thing: heat always moves from warmer to cooler, and cold is just the absence of heat. So all your insulation is really about keeping warm air on the side where you want it. In the winter, that's keeping it inside. In the summer, that's keeping it outside so your house stays cool.

The quiz

We're going to play a little game! I'm going to ask you some questions. Let me grab my pencil so I can keep score.

There are five ways you can buy insulation. Can you name three of the five?

I'm buzzing in! Blown-in insulation, batts of insulation, and rigid foam board.

Yes, those are three of them. Want to try to add the other two?

Rolled insulation. That's like the pink stuff you see in commercials. And sprayed in.

So there's blown-in, which is the loose-fill stuff, and there's sprayed, which is basically spray foam.

I just love the videos of spray foam expanding.

So there are different ways to buy insulation. You can buy it in batts, which are basically sheets. You can buy it rolled up, which I think is the most common one. You can blow it in, and it kind of looks like bunny bedding. You can spray it in, like spray foam. And rigid foam, which is basically sheets of foam. And yes, Benjamin, if you're listening, there are other types. I don't know who Benjamin is, I just picked a guy name. We're talking about the five most common. If you walked into a home improvement store, these are the kinds you would see.

There's also sheep's wool that you can put in walls, which I've actually seen people buy, or denim.

I'm going to give Emily three points and Samantha two.

Boo! It was only because you pressed the imaginary button before I knew the imaginary button existed.

One time we had a buzzer for an episode, and it was so obnoxious we didn't release the episode.

Okay. What are the two main types of batts or rolls? What are they made of?

I hit the button! They're made of fiberglass or mineral wool.

Yes, Samantha gets two. If you've ever handled insulation and you wanted to die, you probably handled fiberglass.

Would you like to guess their R-values? Keep in mind, friends, you want R-value to be a higher number.

First of all, they vary. You can get different R-values. But the traditional R-value for batts is about 21 for fiberglass, and I believe mineral wool is higher, at 30.

I'm not sure that's correct, because I have it per inch.

Oh, I don't know the per inch. I was just going to say that batts are what I'm most used to using, and they come in different thicknesses. The thicker they are, the higher the R-value.

Yes. So fiberglass is around 3 per inch on average.

So if I have 4 inches, my R-value is 12?

Exactly. It's cumulative. And mineral wool is a little bit higher than that, so probably around 3.5 per inch on average.

That's pretty similar.

It is very similar. Emily, I'm going to give you one point for answering, because you were kind of right. Most packaging will list the cumulative R-value, so if it's 3 inches thick, it adds it all together for you. But that's not always the case.

And if you're looking at the pink packaging, it's usually right next to the panther's head. Big letter R, dash, number.

Where does a batt or rolled insulation typically go in your house, Emily?

Between studs or rafters.

Very good. Do you know which studs?

Exterior!

You both get a point. Bonus: if you have insulation in an interior wall, it's either a multifamily property where it's required, or it's for soundproofing.

One tiny bonus: what are each made out of?

Well, fiberglass is literally made of millions of tiny little slivers of glass. Which is insane.

And mineral wool is made from volcanic rock mixed with slag, which is basically a byproduct of making steel.

Wait, that is so much cooler than I thought. Why is it called mineral wool, then?

Because it's made out of minerals.

How do they turn slag and rock into that floofy stuff?

They melt it down, the same way they make fiberglass, and then they put it in a centrifuge.

It's cotton candy!

It is cotton candy, but it's lava cotton candy. Hot lava gets spun around and turned into floof. And that's the same way they make fiberglass, too.

That's unbelievable. Fiberglass makes so much sense, because it literally looks like cotton candy.

Loose-fill (blown-in) insulation

The next section is loose-fill, or blown-in, insulation. What are the two main types?

Fiberglass is one. And cellulose.

Yes, you both get a point.

I know what cellulose looks and feels like, but I don't know what it's made from.

Most blown-in cellulose insulation is made from post-consumer paper products. Unused newspapers or recycled goods, partially pulped and then chunked up and turned into floof. And blown-in fiberglass is made the same way as fiberglass batts, except instead of being fluffed and put on a paper backing, it's compressed into bales. You use a machine that breaks it back up and blows it into your attic.

We used the machine at our first-ever property! The bales are compressed, so you cut them open and have to tear them apart. So picture this: a warm May day, six years ago. Samantha and Emily crawl up into an attic, throw bales of fiberglass at each other, open them, and have a party, like, "This is so fun!" And later we were like, "That was so bad."

And for Benjamin in the comments saying, "That's so stupid": we know. How were we supposed to know? You only have to do it wrong once before you absolutely know. But you don't have to do it wrong, because we just told you. Don't handle it with bare skin!

Can you guess the R-values of cellulose and fiberglass?

Technically, the R-value is ruined if you compress it, so it depends on how deep it is and whether it's compressed.

Can you give me a rough estimate? Which one has a higher R-value per inch?

My guess is cellulose. I'm going to say cellulose also.

Cellulose has a smaller range that sits higher, and fiberglass has a larger range. So on average, it's probably cellulose. Unless it's old and compressed. Then it's not going to be the same.

But the measure is kind of the same. When an inspector checks whether there's enough insulation in an attic, they'll put a yardstick on top of the joist and see how far up the insulation comes. If it's older and compressed, it's lower on the yardstick. It's really a measure of the volume taken up by the floof. That tells you what kind of R-value you're going to get.

Fiberglass is a little bit different, because it doesn't compress as much over time. It stays floofed. That's a new word. Should have put that in the glossary. I'm a certified floofer.

So with cellulose, the thicker it is, the more R-value you get. And with fiberglass, different kinds have different R-values. As a general rule, that's pretty close.

One of the good things about cellulose is it maintains its R-value even in extreme cold. Some foam products actually lose R-value in really cold areas, but cellulose stays consistent. And fiberglass's advantage is that it doesn't settle like cellulose does.

Where do these types of insulation go?

Attics!

Very good. And there's one other place.

You can blow it into the cavities between your studs.

Yes, you can. You either have to make holes in your walls, either inside or on the outside of your house, or, if you have balloon framing, which means your studs run from the basement all the way up in one continuous cavity, you can blow it down from the attic.

But if you have balloon framing and you have knob-and-tube wiring, don't insulate. That's a sidebar, but I have to bring it up.

The other place people generally put it nowadays is wonky-shaped areas, where foam doesn't really make sense.

And do you know why cellulose is fire-retardant if it's paper?

My guess is they coat it with something during manufacturing.

You're both right. It's given a boric acid bath, or sometimes an ammonium sulfate bath, depending on the product. It forces the paper to char instead of bursting into flame.

Oh, it's like for our fire episode, I did a video on the fire-retardant primer. It will char, but it won't set a flame.

Yes! So technically it does burn, but differently. It can get damaged, but it won't spread the fire.

Wrap-up

Can I summarize? If you're a homeowner, what matters is that insulation comes in different formats you can buy it in, and it comes in different R-values. Knowing about R-value means you can talk to your contractor and make sure you're getting the correct R-value. That matters, because it could cost you a couple thousand dollars to pay someone to insulate your attic. And then just understand that it's made of different materials.

And let's put a blanket statement out there, in case you didn't get the gist earlier: fiberglass should never be handled with bare hands or skin. Ever. It's little pieces of glass that will get into your skin like splinters, and it hurts like heckity heck.

And if you get it on you, duct tape can often help pull it out.

I'd like to add one thing that's important as our friends are DIYing: compressed insulation loses its R-value. You can't really compress rigid foam, but with batts, the air is part of the insulating mechanism. That's why double-pane windows have gas or air in between. So if you're DIYing your attic and you have blown-in insulation and you want to lay plywood on top of it, squishing it down ruins its R-value. Or if you have a 3-inch stud cavity and you think, "I'm going to buy 4-inch insulation because it's better," and squish it into 3 inches, you get the benefit of 3 inches. Actually, probably less, because you're getting rid of the air.

So as you're DIYing, don't squish your insulation! Insulation is not for squishing.

If you need a higher R-value for a smaller space, you'll need to find a different product that has a higher R-value per inch. There are certain kinds of fiberglass that take up less space but have a higher R-value per inch, so you can get more out of a smaller space without squishing it. Typically, the higher the R-value, the better it is, but also the more expensive.

There are a couple more products we'll go over eventually, including spray foam and rigid foam. Those are really great homeowner insulations that are super easy to handle.

I'll leave you with a Samantha recommendation: mineral wool batts. They come in rectangles, roughly 2 feet by 4 feet. Those are the absolute easiest for a homeowner to handle and put in. They're friction-fit, so you don't cram them in. You just put them in and they hold between the studs themselves. No nailing, no screwing, no anything. You can cut them, but you can also just tear them, as long as you're wearing gloves. So if you're a homeowner and you want to add insulation somewhere, start your research with mineral wool batts, because they're the easiest for a beginner to handle.

I have homework for our people! If you don't know what type of insulation your home or attic has, I challenge you to go look at it today. When you park your car and go inside, go check out what kind you have. And if you don't have any, that's something to figure out. Then comment below and tell us what kind you have!

This is episode one of insulation. We already have the contents of episode two, and I'm going to suggest that episode three be about diagnosing: "I feel cold air coming from (fill in the blank)," and then here's the insulation that's probably right for that.

Well, friends, thank you for being with us today! Have you checked out our new YouTube series? If not, you should check it out. By the time this episode comes out, all six will be out, or almost all of them. They're for beginners, a gateway into other DIY videos. We're breaking down the basics of the basics. And while you're there, can you subscribe, please? And rate and review, because that helps the show and doesn't cost you anything.

We love you. We'll see you in the next episode! Bye!

Next
Next

What Light Bulb Should I Buy? Kelvins, Lumens and Watts Explained (Plus Where to Put Every Light)